The Harpers run to hide and end up in a space simulator. The other children later attempt to be different superheroes, but the children still prefer Nicky. The Wizards of Oz keep Dawn waiting a long time while they try to decide on what to eat. Good thing Dawn suspected something was wrong with Tess. Problems ensue when two girls see Ricky with Dicky's skateboard and Dicky with Ricky's poetry book. All the children at the party like Ricky, Dicky and Dawn's costumes, but hate Nicky's costume because he doesn't have a good superpower. The War Pigs, led by Nelly, had previously sabotaged the Buffalos' mascot, Mae.
The quads open the gift anyway. In the end, Nicky learns that popularity isn't everything. They finally find Piggly and give him back to Nelly. The boys, determined to attend the concert, break the pact by lying to Mae that Dawn is okay with them going without her. The four then work together to try to hide and repair the damage from their parents, but their scheme is uncovered; however, their mother Anne allows them to keep the dog since she is proud that they were finally able to work together. However, it had been previously stated that they were in fifth grade, meaning they should have been in fourth grade or celebrating their eleventh birthday. During the game, Ricky notices Madison cheating by adjusting a golf ball with her foot.
They all agreed to take that chance and were scared when their father used his new remote to turn it on. The rules of the challenge keep changing until the final version involves fighting with turkey legs. Later, while Ricky is asleep, Nicky, Dicky, and Dawn take away all of his uncool belongings, and Dicky then hides them. It then falls out of the tree. In the show, Lilly uninvites Eiffel from a party, claiming that she makes it odd while Lilly brags as the toilet paper princess.
While trying to figure out why he gave it a good review, they realize that Nicky is the Gourmet Guy. Anne later shows up to find the house a mess, but is not upset with Tom or the children because she was expecting a lot worse. Her family advised her to drop one activity but she claimed that she could do it all. After finally being found out, other friends of theirs stand up in the theater to announce they are also with their parents. However, the trip is in danger of cancellation when no one is willing to accept responsibility for a recent lack of bathroom courtesy. She lies to Nicky and Ricky that she got bit, but admits that she's going through the same changes as Dicky.
Mae can't sleep without folding clothes. Madison invites Ricky to join them at the Boulderly Hills Country Club mini golf course but he doesn't take the offer right away. Dawn is confident they will win this year, but then their hopes are shut down when the Kramden quads show up and announce that they're participating in the race. A big dog then comes up to the quads and shakes slobber all over them. Texting Tina gets detention because she keeps texting in class with her best friend who just moved to Australia. The boys ended up cutting the phone cord and causing her to lose the chance to meet Candace. Instead of Brownie Wilson, she wrote Brownie Squishy Paws.
Ricky comes to Mae's party and starts fighting with his siblings for Mae's attention. The next day, Simone's butler comes to invite the quads except Dicky. After being un-hypnotized, Dawn watches her BeyDawnce video and realizes that if BeyDawnce can sing so well with that confidence in front of people, so can she. However, Principal Tarian gives Natlee a list of safe approved stunts to choose from, but the quads go against the rest of the committee to reject the list. Tom and Anne then growl and stretch their arms out, which makes the quads think that their parents are zombies! Guest stars: Kyla-Drew Simmons as Mae, Mary Birdsong as Ms. They never really became a couple, and since the episode, , Dawn has had another crush on. Both are bumbling man-children, but can be quite handy with building things.
They end up breaking a lot of things in the house. After it escapes the closet and their parents see it, they have to convince them they got it got their mother's birthday, which they forgot about. Her brothers become insecure that Dawn might be more mature. Guest stars: Theodore John Barnes as Miles, Ariana Molkara as Sadie, Sidney Floyd as Brooklyn, Miles Elliot as Kipper, Rena Strober as Ms. Dawn, Dicky and Nicky team up with Mae to take Ricky down by creating an untraceable account called Boco Yolo, which becomes more popular than Ricky's.
This could also qualify as due to the described below. The only thing stopping them is their missing practice skates. When the skates get accidentally burned after the fight, Tom and Anne agree to put a theme that combines all the ideas from their kids. They discover that the new neighbors have a child named Syd and begin plotting on how to use her for their own needs. Dawn finds out that the same tennis balls in the new store explode. After overpowering her brothers and gaining entry into the simulator, she agrees that it was totally worth it. Justified as it was just Ricky's story.
Meanwhile, Mae helps Dawn realize that she's also going through puberty. Dawn may act like the leader of the pack, but deep down, she's just one of the pack. The art contest judges are impressed by the sculptures only to realize that they are actual children and Jackie gets disqualified. The quads feel guilty, thinking that they are the reason their parents despise Valentine's Day, and try to change their parents' feelings about the holiday. She spends most of her time with her brothers, , and. She tells them to keep her inventions secret because she hates when her ideas get out. He then leaves just as Tom and Anne get back from the condo.
The quads become so nervous that they barely sleep that night. At the concert, they try to hide from each other until Dawn's elephant head gets stuck in an elevator door. The quads manage to track him down to El Pepper Pot, but unfortunately this is where their parents are having their date night. The reason in-universe was that Nicky went to a cooking camp. After realizing that Faith, Hope and Susan are falling in love with Joey as well, the boys lie to the girls that Joey is dating Dawn. The cards the quads received for their cabin assignments were the same color as the background in the opening credits for each character. Nicky, Dicky, and Dawn try to convince him otherwise, telling him that everything was set up, when the lights temporarily shut off.